Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Modernity versus Man (Think Piece 1)

In the highly technical and industrialized world of modernity where capitalism (and money) is lording over the once citizen-driven society, the people are the ones who are actually defeated (Arendt, Connolly, Marx, Kant, Foucault). This is not only due to Hobbes’s killing of God nor to Nietzsche’s complete ignorance of an existing God, but to the implicit assumption—however redundant it may sound—that man is a perfect being, master of his own self, who needs no one or nothing else other than his own reason—if it may be considered reason—to live and, as if the world is not enough, transform the society fundamentally, if not leave it ultimately. This is what Arendt elucidates in the Prologue to The Human Condition: That men, in their insatiable quest towards progress (until everything—including religion and history come to an end), desire to escape the earth and live in the universe. They so much long for development so as to eradicate whatever is on earth, because they think that what is given to them is not enough; they go as far as fancying to live eternally. The assumption here, then, is that men have the power and the capacity, not to mention knowledge, to do whatever they want. Apparently, science is, in the final analysis, man’s enemy. Though they may regard it as their best friend,—what with all the scientific discoveries that make life more livable or comfortable or easier, whatever term one satisfies to call it, made through labor and work—by being greatly amazed by scientific progress is no less than a slap in their face. They are dehumanized. In the society thus described, men don’t engage in dialogues with one another, no less than in intellectual discourse (speech), which, according to Arendt, is what politics is all about. According to her, speech is what makes man a political being, and I think speech is what keeps politics alive. Following this logic, politics in the modern age is on its way to its demise, which Arendt is preventing to happen in Chapter I of The Human Condition.

The same focus is explained by Connolly in “The Order of Modernity.” To him, modernity is characterized by thoughtlessness. People no longer think the way the Greeks and the Romans did, hence the total oblivion and death of the richness of tradition. Included in this chapter is a section which talks about the death of God. God, as any Roman Catholic should have been properly taught, is infinite; he is eternal, he doesn’t sleep, he doesn’t die. To say that God is dead is obviously blasphemous, but it is more hubristic than sacrilegious, and to me overt and excessive arrogance is greater evil than blasphemy. What is the basis for this claim? Man is finite, mortal, and—I’d go as far as saying—ridiculous. Evidently, he is the complete opposite of God and his nature. The former is earthly while the other divine. This is probably the reason why man, as described by Arendt, so much wants to escape from the earth: to ultimately break away from what is given to him precisely because he doesn’t recognize the existence of a God who created him. How hubristic! How can a man kill God? But, a closer analysis reveals that it is not man, or a person for that matter, who killed God. It is actually the mind, the thought, the reason. In the final analysis, however, these mind, thought, and reason belong to man. So, using the transitive property in Mathematics (a product of the human mind), if the one who killed God is the mind, and this mind belongs to man, then the one who killed God is man.

Kant’s Enlightenment (as for Foucault) and Marx’s Jewish Question follow similar paths. In general, their thoughts come together to what Connolly coins as the demystification of the political. Kant mentions of legislation as something participated in by the people; Marx talks about emancipation (political and civic). This Kantian idea of legislation as justified by the partaking of the citizens is contradictory to the Greek’s conception of power as visible and politics as mysterious, in the sense that the lawmaking body is outside of it. Kant’s (and Frederick’s) notion of “Argue all you want, but obey!” does nothing but cloud, if not displace, the more acceptable definition and nature of politics. Following this, I find no community in his thought in his idea of enlightenment as maturity, or being independent of others, capable of thinking for oneself. This is visibly not what a community is, and this is the consequence of being too much reliant on one’s own reason or, should I say, knowledge. (Again, this is hubristic!) As for Marx, he appears to be contramodernity as evident in his repudiation of Bauer’s claim that religion needs to be abolished in a secular state for the people in that particular society to be fully emancipated—that is, politically and socially (even humanly). In the end, what Marx says is true, which is about capitalism (as what we can expect from him): that however people may be politically and spiritually liberated, they still remain to be bounded by some material constriction on the basis of economic components. Man, therefore, as a preemption of Hegel as for Kojeve, is a slave of himself.

Patrick Manalo
PoS 61-A

Saturday, September 6, 2008

Islands of Good Governance

The latest Pos 100 plenary series tackled a very crucial issue on Philippine political system that of finding hope through the works of accomplished public servants. Despite blatant corruption plaguing our government from the president down to the baranggay captain level, it can still be said, and I quote Political Science Chair Ms. Alma Salvador in her opening remarks during the forum, there are still “islands of hope”. Though they are few and isolated from each other at the present, their existence galvanizes hope for the youth to look forward and leap into the future of our country. I am speaking here of the invited speakers whom have shared their seemingly impossible accomplishments in governance, namely Governor Teodoro Baguilat of Ifugao Province, Mayor Sonia Lorenzo of San Isidro, Nueva Ecija, and Governor Grace Padaca of Isabela. Two of these great men and women I will talk about.

I especially like what Gov. Baguilat advocates which is appreciation through support and concrete steps for the appreciation of “cultural knowledge” to create a sense of national identity. I like the idea that he still believe Filipino’s can find in themselves a true identity no matter how diverse we are in terms of ethnicity, region, or language. His effort to reach out to Indigenous People (IP) and their concerns exemplifies a Filipino reaching out to his roots, transcending the hindrance of boundaries of geographical and cultural diversity. He is an Ifugao who has embraced his identity foregoing urban lifestyle. And he has extended this experience to other IP’s like the Manobos in Mindanao. His efforts showed how we can all come together if only we approach what we urban oriented Filipino’s consider as traditional, backward, and “paganism”. For according to Gov Baguilat, it is with these people that we will discover and embrace the history of this land, its identity.

Another speaker whom I give one of my highest regard is Gov Padaca. Not only because she was given recently a Ramon Magsaysay award, considered as the Nobel Peace Price in Asia, rather she has accomplished what no able bodied public servant has achieved in terms of a strong advocacy for clean and honest election. Being afflicted with polio, it has not hindered what her spirit can do in terms of promoting good governance in her locality. To quote her saying “No one is too weak or insignificant to make his [her] contribution. I especially like how she accepts the good and bad idea of power. She acknowledges that with right wielding of power one can able bodied or not make a change. We just have to be determined enough.

In a sea of corruption which the Philippines is currently grounded upon there are always signs of hope. Much like how 15th century sea voyagers after months or even years of sailing, jump for joy at the first sight of land, they present hope that with a strong conviction for principles one can still achieve what no ordinary person can even imagine to.

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

The trouble with complacency

This summary is not available. Please click here to view the post.

Sunday, July 13, 2008

Seeing the Political in Romulo Neri’s Appointment as SSS Head.

I just read another news article last week about CHED (or former, I am not sure) chairman Romulo Neri. Apparently GMA has appointed him as the new Social Security System president, replacing Corazon dela Paz. As I was reading the article different, initially malicious, opinions came running through my mind. The name of Mr. Neri was after all a source of headline worthy news during the Lozada, Truth, and ZTE-NBN festival. And even though I was in Cagayan de Oro and missing out on all the “truth” parade in Manila, being updated was a sort of a hobby for me back there. And so I can’t help but attach the ZTE-NBN controversy to the face of Mr. Neri (well that’s the malicious part). However I also pondered on the other side, personality effaced, objective perspective on the issue. There is something politically disturbing about him taking on the as SSS head.

Well the good news is, vehemently speaking, I think Romulo Neri is a man of innumerable credentials for the job of being the new SSS president. He graduated Magna cum Laude in a Business and Finance degree at UP. He held countless positions like chair of National Economic Development Authority Achievements (NEDA). He was also former secretary of Department of Budget and Management (I didn’t know there was such). Ultimately having headed different executive positions in his field of expertise Mr. Neri is, professionally speaking fit to run SSS.

However there is one peculiar character of Mr. Neri that is of a particular interest to me as a Pol Sci Major (naks). If we go back to the ZTE NBN issue, it was not his testimony that made him a “star”. It was actually the opposite; it was his having “no testimony” at all that media and his fan club, the senate that made a frenzy of issue out of him. Sure he did mention some dealings with former COMELEC Benjamin Abalos, he did not give any substancial, juicy, information about the controversial contract itself. It all boil down, or should I say “out”, to him invoking executive privilege. And there was silence…

Now what can we see here? SSS is a public institution, it is owned by the government, and hence it answers to the public. His position is also that of a public official, even though SSS is a government owned corporation. And I think his knack for keeping mum over issues that concern the good of the public and quelling initiations for questions of accountability is a detriment to the our democratic way of governance and it questions and weaken the integrity of the government. For a public official to say that there is nothing to talk about, by invoking executive privilege, tells something about that official’s character as a public servant, moreover it tells something even disturbing about the character of the one who appointed him. The danger posted by this thought is that the check and a balance that enables our democratic system to function is compromised thereby turning our system of governance a joke, us insulted in the process.

I have other, more malicious opinions, on Mr. Neri’s appointment but that’s for another entry if I have time. Or if the issue is still hot. :)

Politics is public. Bow

Phillip Don Recentes
AB political Science

Sorry for grammatical errors. :)

Credit to
http://www.gmanews.tv/story/61990/Romulo-L-Neri
Philippine Daily Inquirer
Philippine Star
My Pos100 teacher for enriching my thoughts on this issue.

Wednesday, July 9, 2008

On the increase of gasoline

Gasoline prices will go up as high as 100 pesos by the end of the year, as most sources say.

Yes this is no joke.

And because of this topic, a lot of people are suffering from the drastic effects: Jeepney fares increasing, less cars, especially those American SUVs on the road, more expensive basic needs and a whole lot more.

We are all bothered by this problem, especially that we were hoping for a much better economy after the drop from 56 to 1 to 41 to 1 last January. All of us are bothered about this. Will this be a repeat of the Asian crisis of 1997? I hope not.

I myself has been feeling the effects, especially since I drive a car to school and given the horrendous prices in gasoline nowadays, I have to plan out my trips to save as much gas as possible. And that's despite I'm driving a diesel car; it would be much much worse with a gasoline car. A 10 peso per liter difference is already a big amount.

Upon reading the news bits about this issue, and by integrating what I have learned from other PolSci classes
with bits of economics (which I still remember despite taking them during 4th year HS). What bothers me is this: What if it is NOT because of scarce resources that keeps the rates high? What if there is someone manipulating things for their own benefit? How about the fate of third world countries like us?

One possible (well not guaranteed to be true) would be that maybe the USA is actually hoarding the oil from the Middle East (known for having abundant resources of oil). I've just noticed somehow that there is something fishy behind the current news. Like what my blockmate said about the rice issue, well it is possible that the USA is hoarding as much oil as it can so it can dominate the market on oil and thus, having control over the prices, leading to a possible monopoly. I know this may be somewhat impossible, but it can be one of the many causes of the increasing oil prices these days. This is just in my opinion.

Feel free to comment.

Duey T. Guison
II AB PoS

*Cross posted on Discover the World

Saturday, July 5, 2008

We Sing, We Dance, We Save the World

II: Assuncion, Martija, Maske, Matibag, Medrano, Omolida

Question: How do we solve poverty?

To answer this question, we begin by first defining the term “poverty”. For us, poverty can be seen under two perspectives that together form a whole. First, poverty is a way of life. It is a principle of complacency and acceptance of mediocrity, so long as the basic necessities of life are satisfied on a day-to-day basis. Moreover, it is a way of thinking, one that has kept the victims of poverty below. Second, objectively speaking, poverty is not having the adequate resources to maintain one’s standard of living. This does not go as far as saying that the term “resources” are constrained only to material things, but also to other necessities that society expects of its people (such as, education, job opportunities, jobs, moral upbringing, character development, work ethics, etc.) to avoid the trap of poverty.

Given this definition, our group proposes a regulation and rehabilitation program, designed for those who live below the poverty line. Informal settlements all over the country will be improved into suburban compounds, where everything will be improved; roads will be paved, a school and health centre will be built, and a local government official (like a barangay captain) will be installed to maintain peace and order. Their shanty houses will be reconstructed with sturdier and safer material. As for the rehabilitation part, there will be seminars and education programs to help the poor get on the right track in using their new community to their advantage. As for the job market, there will initially be a livelihood program, and the members of the community will be compensated for working to build their new and improved suburban settlements.

Title reference: We Sing, We Dance, We Steal Things (2008 album of Jason Mraz)

Friday, June 27, 2008

Should GMA resign or be ousted? by: moran, vergara, guison, reyes, barroa, cupin

TO CHOOSE immediately from what the question poses seems to relegate all action and no thought. First of all, can the country's choices really only be either the forced removal or the voluntary removal of GMA from her seat? Are the two choices even so different in effect? The question automatically assumes that GMA is the cause of whatever political/economic/moral problems that are plaguing the Philippines, and that once she is removed from her seat, we are automatically better off. But the possibility is all too real that our country is distraught with far more complex and less obvious problems (flaws in the government system? the negative outlook of politics to most Filipinos? the political sphere becoming merely an arena for the powerful to maintain power?) of which GMA is only a symptom, and therefore will not and cannot go away even with the coming elections.

As much as we love the legacy of the 1st Edsa Revolution, the whole oust/resign thing is in danger of becoming a little too routine. Even if (or when?) we do decide that GMA must go, we need to consider what we'll do after she leaves before we up and take to the streets. Do we let Noli de Castro assume the role of president? Do we call for a change to the parliamentary system of government? Do we unite with the NPA to oust all our elected officials and instigate communist rule? Whatever the case, we think that what we need is to find the long-term solution to our problems, before we ever get to the luxury of choosing between the resignation of GMA or her ouster.